lupercal
07-20-2007, 02:09 AM
Just wondering if anyone else thought some of the titles in the top or bottom 5's are very unfairly placed.
Actually I'm sure nearly everyone thinks that; I'm just curious about who and what.
For me, though I don't think 'Lord of the Rings' deserves to be called the worst animated film ever made (though it is pretty bad, there are a lot worse),
and I don't think 'Polar Express' is anywhere near bad enough to come in at third worst.
I don't have any problems with the top 5, though I would re-arrange the order, and there are another five films I could probably just as happily see in there.
No huge problems with the DTV top/bottom 5. Mine would be different, but I don't see any really obvious clangers there.
There are several of the 'part live action' films which I've not seen, but no major objections otherwise. WFRR certainly deserves to be number one, and I don't think it ought ever be dislodged, or that it's likely to be.
Minor preferences aside, nothing catastropically 'wrong' with the TV series lists, except I'd rate Tailspin above Avatar, and "The Critic" belongs in the top 5. and 'Futurama' ought to be nudging it.
If there's a short that should beat 'The Wrong Trousers', it's 'Hedgehog in the Fog', but I guess not enough people have seen it.
My problem with the theatrical shorts top 5 is simply that they're all Warner Brothers. I mean, other people did make shorts. Speedo, Calvin Klein, for instance.
Holiday specials" well, I just don't like this type of film much, and there's a couple I haven't seen, so no comment. My personal fave is probably 'Robby the Reindeer', but I'll defer to others' wisdom here.
Loop
Actually I'm sure nearly everyone thinks that; I'm just curious about who and what.
For me, though I don't think 'Lord of the Rings' deserves to be called the worst animated film ever made (though it is pretty bad, there are a lot worse),
and I don't think 'Polar Express' is anywhere near bad enough to come in at third worst.
I don't have any problems with the top 5, though I would re-arrange the order, and there are another five films I could probably just as happily see in there.
No huge problems with the DTV top/bottom 5. Mine would be different, but I don't see any really obvious clangers there.
There are several of the 'part live action' films which I've not seen, but no major objections otherwise. WFRR certainly deserves to be number one, and I don't think it ought ever be dislodged, or that it's likely to be.
Minor preferences aside, nothing catastropically 'wrong' with the TV series lists, except I'd rate Tailspin above Avatar, and "The Critic" belongs in the top 5. and 'Futurama' ought to be nudging it.
If there's a short that should beat 'The Wrong Trousers', it's 'Hedgehog in the Fog', but I guess not enough people have seen it.
My problem with the theatrical shorts top 5 is simply that they're all Warner Brothers. I mean, other people did make shorts. Speedo, Calvin Klein, for instance.
Holiday specials" well, I just don't like this type of film much, and there's a couple I haven't seen, so no comment. My personal fave is probably 'Robby the Reindeer', but I'll defer to others' wisdom here.
Loop