Why is it that so many of Disney's best movies are the 'forgotten' ones? I must admit, on viewing this for the first time in God knows how long, I wasn't expecting to enjoy it that much. I figured it would be just too juvenile plus it was cobbled together out of three older shorts, which were made during the period just before and after Walt's death, which is usually thought to be the studio's lowest ebb.
Surprise of surprises then, albeit WTP _is_ probably aimed at a younger audience than almost all their other features, and despite being stitched together from three short features made over about 8 years, this movie actually works better than anything Disney had made in over fifteen years.
Part of the reason is that it had originaly been conceived as a feature film, before Disney himself decided that it should be split into featurettes, and re-combined at some future date. So esentially the movie finally appeared in the form its producers had intended, some 16 years after the idea was floated.
Inevitably there is a rather episodic feel to the movie, with no over-arching story or quest - however unlike 'Jungle Book' or 'Sword in the Stone', this actually seems to work, and fits in with the whimsical, daydream sort of feel of the movie.
Undoubtedly what is the strongest feature of WTP are the characters, who are all distinct, unique and for the most part wonderfully realised. I say 'mostly', because I found Pooh's voice too adult sounding, and I must admit I don't particularly like him as a character - but he's the only one (though Tigger's voice could have sounded a little younger, too).
I realise that Milne must take a lot of credit for the movie's feel, but Disney for once made the minimum of changes nescessary to render the material workable for a more modern, largely American audience, and I think the original material was treated with a good deal of respect. As I said, there really isn't any particular point to the movie - it feels more like a a pleasant meandering through a colourful, youthful childhood fantasy world.
What pushed it over the edge and gave it that extra half star, for me, was the ending, which was really unexpectedly poignant. In some ways it ranks as one of the saddest scenes in a Disney film, though I suspect it will mainly only seem that way to adults.
The 20th anniversery edition (or 25th, or whatever) apparently features a fourth featurette, 'Pooh-Sticks' (which I remember as a story from my childhood). I'm not sure what this does to the movie, though it does concentrate more on Eeyore, who didn't get a lot of screen time in the original version, so it may be a good thing. Still, this review applies only to the original three-story version.