Keyframe
User Name
Password  
The Animation
Search for Animation:
Animation Industry Keyframe Community About Community
(rating: 3.75 stars / 2 reviews)
Animation > Short Film / Part Live-Action
Reviews for The Flat
posted: Mar 25, 2006
Rated it:
Avatar image
World-Class Animation Critic
Very good review below. This is one of my favourite early Svankmajer shorts, and like most of his shorts, it keeps growing on you. What it makes very plain is, despite his reputation for dark, serious, incomprehensible films, the guy has a sense of humour. A lot of 'The Flat' is funny. But it's funny in ways which can be easily related to two themes which pervaded Svankmajer's work of the period - either by choice or necessity.

The first is the ever-hovering motif of mortality, decay and death. Of the helplessness of the individual against cosmic forces beyond his control. The nameless protagonist is thrust into a malevolent flat (rather like the child in his later 'Down to the Cellar'), and soon discovers not only that he is trapped in it, but that it wishes him ill - injuring him, playing tricks on him. Mind you, some of these episodes are rather funny. My favourite is where he sits down to eats some sausages, hears a noise coming from the closet, opens it, and a pack of dogs leap out, eat the sausages and leap back in again.

The other theme which must have informed his work was the repression of life and the arts under Soviet rule. It wasn't long after this that he was banned from making films for about 5 years. So, seen from this perspective, the flat represents the malicious repression of the state.

Whether Svankmajer is referring to death, authoritarianism or both, the individual is helpless against it, and in this film the protagonist accepts his ordeals with a sort of numb resignation, drained of resistance.

I won't spoil the ending for you, but it only confirms the themes of the rest of the film.

As for the guy who walks in, in slow motion, petting a rooster, offers him an axe, and walks out again, still petting the rooster... you tell me (and then you can explain to me the rooster-man in 'Conspirators of Pleasure)

A classic short. Nothing else quite like it.

posted: Mar 24, 2006
Rated it:
Avatar image
KF Web Animation Editor
This characteristically bizarre Svankmajer film is reminiscent of a slapstick silent; this is reinforced by the fact that the hero rarely looks more than slightly bemused by the goings on. But instead of a series of comedic mishaps, the hapless protagonist is subjected to a long string of cruel pranks played on him by the flat, like Charlie Chaplin's nightmares or some kind of sadistic video game. There are also echoes of the Greek myth of Tantalus, whose punishment in the underworld was to be placed near food that always moved away from him.

Not only does the room appear to actually be alive, but it also seems as if it can change shape. Using sequences of close-up shots Svankmajer creates the illusion of a room that's smaller than it actually is; these morphs in space are reflected in the music, which is sometimes comical, sometimes hellishly frantic.