I think 'The Grinch' is a very good short, but I don't think it's a masterpiece. I'm sorry to break this film's unbroken run of 4.0 stars, but it's not as if I've been living 'in a hole' all my life. It's more that I don't have any rose-tinted glasses to watch this through. Up until the Jim Carey version of the story (which I've never seen) I'd never heard of it, and until a few weeks ago I'd never even seen a copy of it to review (that I can remember.)
This seems to be because The Grinch is a very North American phenomenon. In Australia it certainly isn't a perrenial classic that everyone should watch twice a year. Most people here probably don't know the 1966 animated version even exists. It's not that Dr Seuss isn't well known. I went through a brief Seuss phase as a kid. He just seems to be a national instituion in the US/Canada, whereas here he's just a well known children's writer.
Because of which I'll assume most of my audience know the story. The reviews below have told you what's great about this short, now I'll tell you what, from my POV stops it getting those four stars.
Firstly the animation. I'm sorry, but it isn't amazing or awesome. It looks like Chuck Jones doing the best he can with 60's limited TV animation. In other words, Warner shorts of 20 years earlier would put it to shame. What does shine through is Jone's great direction, timing, facial expressions, pacing and so forth, but that's great direction more than great animation.
Secondly, I wonder if I'm not more sympathetic to The Grinch than The Whos. To me they seem a tiresome bunch of Brady-Bunch like, wholesome, god-fearing, irritating pains in the neck, and if I lived near them, they'd probably drive me mad as well.
Thirdly, the Grinch's sudden 'conversion' from a hopeless cynic to a hopeless romantic in the space of a few seconds can only be attributed to an act of God or bipolar disorder. It just isn't credible. I understand that little kids probably won't worry about that, but I do.
The main song is overused and gets boring.
Having said that, Jones does a terrific job as director. Many of the Grinch's facial expession could be transplanted straight onto Bugs Bunny. The pacing is great; I like Max the Dog; Karloff is very good as narrator and Grinch (Bela Lugosi would have been interesting, but he was already dead), and the film sets out what it means to achieve, which is to be a unique, feel-good Christmas story, working well within the restraints of its technology and budget. Nevertheless it's 3.5 stars from me are a little hard-won.
A very worthy little film, and certainly worth watching, but not, IMO, a masterpiece.