Cartoon violence is on the whole a thing that can be quite brutal, yet the reason that most of it is funny is because it is devoid of reality. When Jerry chops off Tom’s tail, the feline leaps into the air a short, sharp scream of pain is heard. Then he lands and the pain is over; tail is back on body, the chase renews. When Daffy gets shot in the beak, his usually reaction is more disgruntlement than pain as he picks up and replants his beak back on his face. When an object lands on their head a character smashes like china, but is back next scene as if nothing happened. It’s this distance from reality that makes it funny. In cartoons bodies renew, broken teeth are replaced. You see things that just can’t happen in real life and the character bounce back from it; that surreal factor gives it the humor.
Remember this line from Roger Rabbit…
“No he’s a toon, you can drop anything you want on his head he’ll shake it off…”
And that’s the whole point, violence minus pain is funny; it’s called slapstick and long has it been a tradition of humor on stage and screen (Hey live action series The Young Ones and Bottom turned pretend violence into an art).
Happy Tree Friends is different, by removing this simple principal it turns itself into something which is quite disturbing and utterly wrenched. Watching these characters in what passes for real pain isn’t fun, it’s unsettlingly.
The friends themselves all look like rejects from the Care Bears, including having little hearts for noses; apart from Lumpy who’s resemblance to Bullwinkle (both physically and mentally) is uncanny. Have the creators got something against these characters, maybe, though the truth is probably due to them wanting the characters to look as cute as possible. This was something that helped South Park, with its Peanut-like character design, but it had a cutting-wit and differential plotlines; and it also created the concept of killing one of its characters (the unfortunate Kenny).
Its inanity isn’t helped by its repetitiveness, watching nearly the same dull setup over and over again and anticlimactic, you know what’s going to happen; the character is going to die. There’s no variation on plot, or anything to keep you coming back unless your sense of humour is that sordid.
It a one trick pony, or should that be donkey; actually I don’t think it deserves to be compared to either quadruped.
NB: Oh yeah as far as I can tell, the TV series and DVD's are just made up of the web episodes.