'Cool World' is probably unique amongst Ralph Bakshi's films, in that even he doesn't like it. He even accused an interviewer of cruelty for bringing the subject up. Which is ironic, because it probably made more money than any of his previous films, though the critics didn't like it much.
It's easy to see why such a cranky individualist as Bakshi would be unhappy with what happened to this film. In his original concept, the main human and animated characters have a baby, which is a hybrid monster - half animated - half alive. "I wanted to do the first animated horror film", he later said. At the inception of the project he was delighted that people with money were letting him do his own thing.
Naturally the studios, who for once were giving Bakshi a budget that he could do something with, found this completely unacceptable, and the script and entire concept of the movie was re-written for him in mid-production. This resulted in Bakshi punching producer (and Paramount boss's son) Frank Mancuso Jr. in the mouth.
Worse was to come. Kim Bassinger (Holli) thought the new, clean version was great (Bakshi claimed she thought she would be able to show it sick children in hospital). Bakshi apparently couldn't stand her, and would fight with her constantly on set. He later stated that Mancuso probably had his hand up Bassinger's pants.
Effectively this is the one Bakshi film where Bakshi has to surrender some creative control to the guys with the money. Bakshi wanted to make a Bakshi film. Paramount wanted to make something that would make money... y'know, like Roger Rabbit.
Predictably the result is neither a dazzling big studio classic, or a memorable, low-budget , quirky Bakshi cult film. I remember watching this when it came out on VHS with two housemates. One declared it was good. The other thought it pretty much sucked. I'm inclined to the latter's POV, though with reservations.
Had someone thrown a large amount of money at Bakshi and said 'go make your movie' (which I might add has NEVER happened), then 'Cool World' could indeed have been cool. It does have the exoskeleton of a good movie about it. An adult, logical, dark and troubling extension of Who Framed Roger Rabbit. I'm sure he would have made up in style what he lacked in technique. Instead we get a faltering, ultimately not very interesting and rather puerile plot, which additionally doesn't come near the technical genius of Roger Rabbit.
It's not a train wreck - I don't even think it's QUITE RB's worst film - but it has little of the feel of a Bakshi film, even a bad one. And it's Bakshi's distinctive style that kept me coming back for more, even when I was disappointed more often than not after 'Wizards'.
This was Bakshi first feature film in nearly 10 years, and he hasn't made one since. As he put it, 'Cool World' was where he "learned about corporate animation".
After that he took up painting.