After the Fairy Godmother finishes reading the story of Cinderella to her devoted mice friends, the mice decide to give a storybook of their own to Cinderella. They tell the tales of Cinderella's first days in the castle when she was still trying to figure out how to be her own kind of princess, the story of how Jacques thought he'd be more help to Cinderella if he were human, and the story of how Cinderella's step-sister, Anastasia, fell in love for the first time.